G'day Gman. Thanks for posting those pics, they're excellent and a great contribution to the thread.
I'll offer my own thoughts on your mower, for what they're worth

Firstly, the serial number would suggest it is out of the range for a genuine Auto. Evidence so far collected suggests a range of 110,000 to around 127,000 to be correct for the Automatic, but that's not yet set in stone. Along with any information on the Auto, new evidence is appearing all the time, and as such,the record is constantly being amended. This thread is a testament to that!
I tend to run through a checklist of features when identifying an Auto. Firstly, the serial should sit within the range I mentioned. Secondly, does it have an Auto badge. Many mock-up Automatics have been assembled over the years, and equally, many Autos have lost their badges, so the presence of a badge must be considered, but in no way relied upon.
Thirdly, does the mower have skirt retaining bolts. These four bolts are notoriously fragile, and are very difficult to remove. Often, any attempt to remove them will sheer them off leaving half the bolt in the deck. The complete absence of bolts, or evidence of them having been there for a true Auto would be very rare and not something I personally have ever seen.
Fourthly, the fuel cap should be painted green. Allot of misinformation and hearsay has alluded to painted fuel caps being fakes. This is point blank untrue as the evidence demonstrates. Early Auto's ran an opaque plastic cap painted with Hammertone, whilst the later stages of the model ran a green plastic cap, which was also painted. From what I have seen, all of the Model 4 Specials ran the same green plastic cap, but they were unpainted. Again, this is not to be relied upon as an indicator of authenticity, as the paint often wore off over time.
My fifth check is the carby. It should have the twin throttle cap and brass slide, with both ports on the cap having been drilled and threaded. Often, caps appear that have two ports, with only one of which that's been drilled. These appeared right up into the Model 5 so should be disregarded as being evidential of being an Automatic.
Next we have the fuel tap. It should be of the cigar type, but these also appeared in after market form with grooved casings, so beware. Finally, the starter appeared in two styles during the life of the model one, but a uniform trait was the green rubber cover on the started handle. As far as I know, the black rubber handle appeared during the life of the model 5.
A few other variable indicators are demonstrated during the life of the Automatic, including painted axle housings for the earlier model examples, and large dome nuts on the handlebar clamp changing to long hex later in the serial run. Once all these factors are considered, I then move onto the Predicta mechanism, or most often lack there of. As you mentioned, mowers that formerly had the setup often leave evidence of this. I've always considered broken axle housing retaining clips as a good indicator of a front or rear flap having been torn away. Equally, prominent signs of wear in those areas is also a good indicator of a now missing Predicta mechanism. While there are many other considerations, this is the basic checklist I run through.
In regards to your mower, my own subjective opinion is that it began life as a Model 4 Special (Standard) from mid 1958, which would have come without a starter or badge. I've got one just like it in the 154,000s. I suspect that at some point somebody has added the badge, carby and a later model 5 starter and groove cover, perhaps to create their own Automatic, but I'm often wrong, so don't count on it! There is speculation that many Auto parts were simply "used up" after the demise of the Automatic and may have been added on the assembly line, but regardless of this being fact or fiction, true examples of the Automatic should tick many if not all of the boxes I mentioned above.If nothing else, your mower demonstrates what is often confused for the genuine article, and they often come up. Regardless of all that, I think it's a great mower with some rare parts, especially that Model 5 rubber starter cover!
Thanks again for posting
