No harm in getting a quote for a new catcher, but don't be surprised when you see the price. It is fairly well used as can be seen.
For me, it comes down to what the machine will be used for. If it's an every day machine, you can knock out the obvious bits yourself and slap some fillers in the rest, but if you're going for a showroom finish then a new one will be more economical and far better looking.
TC.
