Sorry Converse but I have to ask why? it is just a Victa catcher, millions of them available off the side of the road or for a couple of dollars on ebay. The problem with the metal repair sections is that they make the catcher heavy. Personally I would go for the middle pic. If I have to do those type of repair I use 3/16th rivets and I then make up washers to put on the other side of the plastic so the plastic is sandwiched between the repair panel and the washer
